A few days ago one of my favorite bloggers Cat Chapin-Bishop of Quaker Pagan Reflections did a guest-post over at The Wild Hunt (another read of mine) in which she puts forth the following request:
“Don’t tell me that community is important in Paganism. Tell me about finding your first Pagan community, and about that heady rush like first love you felt for it. And about the crushing pain that followed the first betrayal (the leader that was manipulative; the grove member who stole; the coven-mate whose oaths didn’t keep her from outing one of you) and how you came to terms with it. How you learned to embrace the Pagan world despite its flaws–or dedicated yourself to eradicating them.” (emphasis mine)
I came to Wicca in 1988, at the end of my Freshman year of college. After literally years of trying to find a way to balance the things I had come to believe in (psychic ability, magic, tarot, reincarnation, a feminine face to the Divine, the sanctity of the natural world, etc) with the doctrine of the Roman Catholic church I found myself researching Witchcraft at my college campus’ library. My purpose of the time was geared more toward spellcraft, but when I found (and devoured in one sitting) the book Witchcraft: The Old Religion by Dr. Leo Louis Martello I knew I had found a name for all those things that I believed in. I had found my path and from that moment I gave up trying to stay Catholic and embraced Witchcraft.
By the following fall, back at college, a friend and I (along with her fiancee) attended the first meeting of a Pagan study group and promptly started a friendship with the boy/man who ran the group. In fact, at his invitation I wound up attending my first open circle by Candlemas of 1989. Eventually he & I became romatically involved and my friends started coming to open circles as well in time. By the time the circle disbanded in late 1992 I had attained my 3rd degree initiation (yes I know I was a little shy of “a year and a day” times 3 but my second degree initiation was moved up in order to allow he and I to take that step together) but had been betrayed by two of the people who I called friends, coven-mates, and heart family.
The first betrayal came at the hands of my lover who, when we took a female friend into our bed (my one and only attempt at polyamory), fell in love with her too. This led to my having to move out of the apartment he & I had just set up a few months prior and triggered one of the most painful years of my life as he & I continued to date (with him often speaking of “when we would get engaged again”) while he was dating “her”.
I never blamed him (or at least I tried not to) and our relationship continued for another year or so before I finally had enough and ended it. Don’t get me wrong the loss of the relationship hurt. I had been convinced that he was going to be my life-mate and that eventually he & I would branch off from Lady Rose’s coven and form our own as Priest and Priestess. It was this sureity that was the cause of my holding on for so long to a dead relationship. But, the betrayal in my mind came not from his following his affections to the arms of another but from how eventually I lost him as a friend as well when he took another person’s side in the next scenario.
A few months later another love affair went awry in that a man who had asked me with tears in his eyes to be exclusive decided almost as soon as he had me that he didn’t really want only me after all. So soon on the heels of being cast aside I (stupidly) accomodated his request to be able to see other people. I knew my roomate (coven-mate and friend) had her eye on him and as she was ….. hmmm …… open and free with her own sexuality I asked her to not sleep with him while he and I were still dating.
One night I went out to see a play with a friend and came home to the unmistakable sounds of them screwing in her bedroom. I was embarassed and angry and hurt. This was made worse by her insistance that I had no right to tell her what to do with her body and that the Rede (an’ it harm none, do what ye will) didn’t apply because she could only hurt me if I chose to be hurt. The implication was also there that if I was more spiritual and less hung-up that there wouldn’t be a problem.
I have to say honestly that my former friend and roommate’s betryal struck deeper than even the losing of either love affair. We were members of the same faith and of the same circle and yet our views on fairness and morality were so far apart. She had her world-view and was unable or unwilling to see past it to the fact that, right or wrong, that I was hurt by her actions. For her, at that time in her life, being “right” meant more to her than my friendship.
When it became clear that she and I could never be in the same circle again (and rather than have her banned from the coven or cause me to feel the need to walk away) the choice was made to disband. I always hoped that Lady Rose would form another circle but life didn’t play out that way. I always figured I’d find another coven the same way I found my first one …. Id meet the right person at the right time …. but over 15 years of being a solitary later that doesn’t seem to be in the cards either.
Insofar as coming to terms with it, I never really have. Both soul-wounds are like scars that you find yourself rubbing without thinking about it only to realize too late that you’ve made them sore. I don’t look for another coven because in truth I would fully expect to be betrayed again. I don’t share my faith with many people and when I do happen to meet a likeminded person I am more intimidated than intrigued.
I am hoping that next month’s trip to Womongathering will help me begin to move past those old hurts, network a little, and to find my spirit soaring within sacred space again.
Blessings
Mama Kelly






























